Southern Religion

When are militia Christianist (not Christian)?

Andrew Sullivan is a gay Catholic who gently suggests:

Surely we can all assent to the notion that a Christian militia of the type now accused of planning domestic terrorism is not Christian. This is why I call them Christianist. Anyone planning to murder innocents by way of IEDs cannot plausibly call himself or herself a follower of Jesus of Nazareth.

To which Skeptic PZ Myers replied at some easy-to-read length, asserting that there are Christians (the real thing). And Christianists, a term William Safire traced back to Andrew Sullivan, who on June 1, 2003, wrote:

I have a new term for those on the fringes of the religious right who have used the Gospels to perpetuate their own aspirations for power, control and oppression: Christianists. They are as anathema to true Christians as the Islamists are to true Islam.”


No friend of matters mystical, Myers of course fences almost everyone we know up with Christianists, but that’s a part of what he does. Whereas most of us may seriously entertain the possibility that the Hutaree are Christianists. And we are not.


March 31, 2010 - Posted by | Cults, Politics, Religion | ,


  1. There’s a good chance that these guys ended up as “Elite Media Journalists” and were experts in many fields.

    Comment by jack | March 31, 2010

    • You’re being sarcastic.
      You know of course that Andrew Sullivan writes for The Atlantic Monthly, is former editor of The New Republic, is author of four books and writes one of the world’s most read blogs.
      While PZ Myers is a professor of evolutionary and developmental biology who is probably the world’s top atheist blogger and top-ranked scientific blogger.
      You’re definitely being sarcastic.

      Comment by baptistplanet | April 1, 2010

  2. […] (8)  Cuando se christianist milicia (no cristiano)? […]

    Pingback by TraVotez | April 2, 2010

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

%d bloggers like this: