A death every 12 minutes from lack of health insurance
While Baptist Press promoted Kelly Bloggs’ shrill, CounterFactual, anti-abortion attack on health care reform, Eduardo Peñalver of Cornell Law School struggled with the daily human-life cost of U.S. health policies. Writing for the Catholic site dotCommonweal, Peñalver cited a new Harvard Medical School study which says:
Nearly 45,000 people die in the United States each year — one every 12 minutes — in large part because they lack health insurance and can not get good care, Harvard Medical School researchers found in an analysis released on Thursday. “We’re losing more Americans every day because of inaction … than drunk driving and homicide combined,” Dr. David Himmelstein, a co-author of the study and an associate professor of medicine at Harvard, said in an interview with Reuters
Those were not concerns for Florida Baptist Witness editor James Smith, who was consumed with a conjectural cost in unborn lives, with fantasies of rationed health care and with attempting to prove Obama dishonest in his abortion reduction policies. On that last point, Smith’s arguments finally relied so heavily on arguments made by the National Right to Life Committee that they become almost identical to them. And he closes with a risible reference to “the danger inherent to the elderly” of rationed health care, as if health care were not already rationed. FactCheck.org tells us, and PolitiFact.com agrees, that no version of the health reform legislation proposes new health care rationing.
Peñalvers focused instead on the overarching life issue posed by the deaths of the uninsured and by abortion deaths. Both. He acknowledged the argument that those newly insured via health reform might use resources thus freed up to help pay for an abortion.
What he further considers, but Boggs and Smith do not, is the larger issue:
… wouldn’t this abortion-facilitating argument be equally true for any government subsidy of the poor? How, for example, is it different from saying that we should not give the poor food stamps because (for some undetermined number of people) that will free up money from their personal budgets that they will then use to go out and procure an abortion that they otherwise would not have been able to afford? Should we require food-stamp recipients to sign some pledge that they won’t use their private money to procure abortions? Given the various positions that Obama has taken to try to defuse the abortion issue in the health care context, that it may nonetheless indirectly subsidize abortions strikes me as a very odd argument against Catholics supporting health care reform.
It is similarly odd for Southern Baptists to lose themselves in sweeping claims that the president “and his base supporters in Congress” have an unacknowledged abortion agenda.
If the issue is indeed preservation of life, the Harvard study tells us there is a death every few minutes which suggests that it is not enough to seek fewer abortions.
September 20, 2009 - Posted by baptistplanet | Catholic, Churches, Health, Politics, Religion, SBC | abortion, Barack Obama, health reform, Southern Baptist Convention
2 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
About BaptistPlanet
BaptistPlanet is a multiblog written by two prize-winning, veteran, mainstream daily newspaper and online journalists. Both Southerners. We cover every aspect of religion news that is of interest to our audience.
Categories
Top Posts
Recent Comments
Scott Rose on Civil marriage debate is owed… cinhosa on Another Christian woman gives… baptistplanet on Another Christian woman gives… cinhosa on Another Christian woman gives… Chicago’s Cardinal F… on Chicago’s Cardinal Franc… Catholic mass on Six+ decades of Dutch Roman Ca… Our del.icio.us
Tags
abortion abstinence Anglican anonymous blogging anti-abortion anti-Semitism Atlanta Baptist Barack Obama Cameroon Catholic Catholic church CDC children child sexual abuse child trafficking Christian Christianity Christmas clerical predators clerical sexual abuse clerical sexual predation condoms creationism cult culture wars deacons Eddie Long Episcopal evolution Faith-Based Initiatives FBC Jax Florida gay genocide global warming Great Commission Resurgence Great Commission Resurgence Task Force Haiti hate crime health care reform health reform homophobia homosexual homosexuality human rights International Mission Board Jacksonville journalism Legionaires of Christ lgbt rights Marcial Maciel Muslim Obama pedophile priests Pope Benedict XVI Regnum Christe Religion Religious Right Richard Land Rick Warren roman catholic church same-sex marriage Sarah Palin SBC Scientology sexual predators Southern Baptist Southern Baptist Convention SSPX Ted Haggard Texas Uganda Vatican Wade Burleson womenBlogs by Month
Catholic News Service
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Associated Baptist Press
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Spiritual Politics
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Stop Baptist Predators
- Hopeless and Hopeful: Reflections on the past and thoughts for the future
- Common misconceptions about the Baylor sexual assault scandal
- SBC church seeks to 'out' child sex abuse victims
- Southern Baptists elect known clergy-sex-abuse-cover-upper as president
- SNAP prediction: Next "Spotlight"-style exposé will focus on Baptists
- What's wrong with the "sexual predation" resolution
- Why Ted Cruz should see "Spotlight"
- Spotlight: Lessons to be Learned
- "Frankly, this ruling is appropriate ...."
- Mitigating the trauma of clergy sex abuse
Tony Cartledge
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Religion Clause
- 4th Circuit: Denial of Opt-Out From LGBTQ-Friendly Books Did Not Violate Parents' Free Exercise Rights
- Mississippi Enacts Law Defining "Sex" In Biological Terms
- 2nd Circuit Reverses Dismissal of Muslim Inmate's Complaint About Eid Meal
- 11th Circuit: Excluding Sex Change Surgery from Health Plan Violates Title VII
- 18 States Sue EEOC Over Guidance on Transgender Sexual Harassment
- New Report Finds 63% of Americans Support Legalized Abortion
- European Court: Romania Violated European Convention When It Reversed Conviction of 2 Nazi War Criminals
- Recent Articles of Interest
- Washington State AG Investigating Sex Abuse Cover-Up by Catholic Diocese
- Religious Discrimination Claim for Denial of Personal Leave Moves Ahead
Grace & Truth to You
- Wade Burleson at Istoria Ministries Is Now A Substack Subscription
- "A Revolution that Began in the Hearts and Minds of the American People" - by President John Adams
- Graced People Reap What They Have Not Sown; Lost People Reap What They Have Sown
- Wade Burleson Is Now at Istoria Ministries
- 2021 World's Tallest Live Christmas Tree, Enid, OK
- Be My Thou Thanksgiving Vision: A Prayer for All
- Chasa Boudin and San Francisco's Crime Wave
- Let's Be Thankful that "This Is My Father's World"
- Addictions and the Goal to Control God's Thoughts
- The Potential Discovery of Lt. Col. Leon "Bob" Vance's Crashed Army Air Corp Air Ambulance
Get Religion
- Farewell, after 20 years: Why we did what we did
- Peter J. Boyer: Charged with covering faith for The New Yorker, I found GetReligion
- Salute from Will Norton at Ole Miss: Religion plays a crucial role in news -- around the world
- Closing one door: Whither 21st Century religion and our beleaguered news media?
- Thomas A. Szyszkiewicz: A farewell to GetReligion from Catholic radio
- Archbishop Charles J. Chaput: The religion beat is where 'our defining freedoms meet'
- Julia Duin: It's been a long road and we've reached the end of our GetReligion journey
- A salute from north of the border, care of CBC Radio veteran Anna-Liza Kozma
- Farewell from Moscow: This American ran into GetReligion online and never stopped reading
- Kenneth Woodward: GetReligion, in so many ways, kept offering on-the-job training
Faith in Public Life
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
dotCommonweal
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Capital J
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
@baptistplanet on twitter
Tweets by baptistplanet
It is astonishing, that in this day, we still have no answer to no insurance. Money can be replaced, while people cannot.
Comment by Juan Batista | September 26, 2009
How many people die from not exercising and overeating? You cannot solve the world’s problems by throwing money at them. People need to take more personal responsibility for their health. – We’re being taxed to death. Not too long ago, people ate in moderation, exercised outdoors and had family members to take care of them when they were sick. What happened?
Comment by Yvonne | October 14, 2009