CounterFactual Kelly Boggs [Addendum]
“President Obama recently expressed his concern over mercenary medical professionals,” editor Kelly Boggs wrote in a Sept. 3 Louisiana Baptist Message editorial.
Boggs’ logic moved quickly to judgment of the presidents July 22 news conference:
The President offered no evidence to support his claim that dollar-drunk docs are performing all manner of unnecessary medical procedures. There were no statistics supporting his claim that patients are mere prey for money-grubbing physicians; not even an anecdote was offered.
Thus Boggs implied that no such statistics and anecdotes were readily available.
Before implying that the president was misleading us, Boggs had a journalistic obligation to look for statistics and anecdotes. Failure to do so is, among professional journalists, a form of disregard for the truth.
Looking just a little would have showed Boggs that his argument was not exactly right.
The Congressional Budget office estimates 16% of the Gross Domestic Product — about $700 billion a year — “goes to healthcare spending that can’t be shown to improve health outcomes.”
One readily discovered anecdote is Consumer Reports’ account of Ron Spurgeon’s unnecessary cardiac bypass surgery at Redding Medical Center in northern California. Spurgeon “and 344 others sued the hospital and eight cardiologists and surgeons for performing unnecessary procedures. The defendants ultimately paid $442 million to settle the suit.”
Neither the CBO numberss nor the availability of anecdotes should surprise anyone.
The problem to which Obama alluded is so commonplace that CBS had on June 10 ran a consumer-information feature warning that as many as 40% of all medical procedures are unnecessary and explaining how consumers can protect themselves.
But Boggs was in a hurry. The reality or lack thereof of greedy doctors wasn’t his primary concern. Abortion was. Having castigated Obama for lack of statistics and anecdotes, Boggs wrote:
But let’s assume for the sake of argument the president is correct and mercenary medicine is indeed out of control in America. The one area he needs to set his sights on cleaning up first is those physicians who perform abortions.
Boggs argues that “85 to 90 percent, and more, of all abortions are carried out as a result of convenience” and fuel “a lucrative industry.” Apparently to illustrate how lucrative, he wrote:
Planned Parenthood, America’s largest abortion provider, rakes in more than a billion dollars every year. And while PP is the largest peddler of elective abortions, it is by no means the only one. Needless to say, there is a lot of money available to greedy doctors willing to perform an unnecessary medical procedure.
Not exactly.
It is true Planned Parenthood is a nonprofit corporation with a total budget of about $1 billion a year.
Yet as Wikipedia makes clear, Planned Parenthood’s budget isn’t the result of “raking in” abortion profits:
In 2007, contraception constituted 36% of total services, STI/STD testing and treatment constituted 31%, cancer testing and screening constituted 17%; other women’s health services, including pregnancy, prenatal, midlife, and infertility were 11%, and approximately 3% of total services involved surgical and medical abortions.
. . .
Planned Parenthood receives about a third of its money in government grants and contracts ($349.6 million in FY 2008). In the 2007–08 Annual Report, clinic income totaled $374.7 million and miscellaneous operating revenues $68.9 million. Planned Parenthood is also heavily sponsored by private individuals, with over 700,000 active individual contributors [.pdf] Large donors such as the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation contribute a substantial part of the organization’s budget.
Undeterred by reality, Boggs charges on to his central point:
So, if President Obama is really serious about reforming health care by reducing the number of medically unnecessary procedures he will certainly call for the end of elective abortions, right?
That’s the first in a series of rhetorical questions with which Boggs hectors his readers. It’s rhetorical because Obama’s pro-choice views are well-known.
Boggs’ questions do bring us to his concluding erroneous argument — that health reform will use government funds to pay for abortion. His proof is an Aug. 5 news story:
In fact, the Associated Press recently reported, “Health care legislation before Congress would allow a new government-sponsored insurance plan to cover abortions…”
The ellipses are his, BTW, and the AP story is not exactly the final word .
On August 7 PolitiFact.com examined the same issue. It did so by way of evaluating a claim by Rep. John Boehner (R-Ohio) that “The Democrat-backed health care reform plan “will require (Americans) to subsidize abortion with their hard-earned tax dollars.”
After exploring the matter in detail, PolitiFact concluded that “things could change as the health reform package works its way through Congress, but for now, we don’t see anything to support Boehner’s claim that taxpayers would subsidize abortions. And so we rule his statement False.”
Also not exactly right is Boggs’ conclusion that “If the president has his way, not only will medically unnecessary, elective abortion on demand continue unabated in America, it will be underwritten by the government and will likely only increase.”
Obama’s campaign commitment was to abortion reduction, an issue covered in detail by in a Sept. 14 Associated Baptist Press article by David Gushee, Joel Hunter and Ronald Sider.
The three wrote in rebuttal to a Baptist Press article, which they argue misportrayed the recently introduced Preventing Unintended Pregnancies, Reducing the Need for Abortion, and Supporting Parents Act (H.R. 3312, referred to as the Ryan-DeLauro Bill).
Gushee, Hunter and Sider aren’t counterfactual. They don’t hector their readers with rhetorical questions. They do conclude:
Common-ground efforts to reduce abortion by addressing the circumstances that lead to it are consistent with the conviction that all life — the unborn, pregnant women, infants and children — is sacred. Honest dialogue about this innovative approach is imperative for those of us who aspire to protect life in concrete ways.
Plainly misrepresenting the content of the Ryan-DeLauro bill, and asserting in defiance of logic and evidence that it will increase rather than reduce abortion, does nothing to protect life. In fact, it does the opposite.
Likewise abortion reduction is President Obama’s clearly stated goal. Not exactly what Boggs says in his closing summary.
Addendum: Another anecdote
CounterFactual Boggs was so distressed at President Obama’s failure to offer anecdotes at his July 22 news conference that we’re adding another to the one already provided.
Adam Linker writes of a “physician who visited the emergency room when he came down with shingles. The doc, who teaches at Stony Brook University, got caught in a maze of over testing and ran up an unnecessary $9,000 bill.” The physician’s tale of expensive, time and money wasting, medically unproductive woe concludes:
One thing’s for sure: I’ve lost the smugness and condescension I often felt when listening to others’ stories about being trapped by the system and manipulated into excessively complex and specialized medical situations. Unlike most of my patients, I actually knew what my diagnosis was and what to do about it, but I learned how difficult it is to remain objective when you’re feeling very sick. Maybe I should have been more assertive. Instead, I wound up as a poster boy for excessive medicine. I understand now how all those people could have been so gullible, so easily manipulated by the system. Now that I’m one of them, that is.
Boggs and others may read Linker’s entire post here.
September 20, 2009 - Posted by baptistplanet | Health, Religion, SBC | abortion, Baptist, Barack Obama, culture wars
3 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
About BaptistPlanet
BaptistPlanet is a multiblog written by two prize-winning, veteran, mainstream daily newspaper and online journalists. Both Southerners. We cover every aspect of religion news that is of interest to our audience.
Categories
Top Posts
Recent Comments
Scott Rose on Civil marriage debate is owed… cinhosa on Another Christian woman gives… baptistplanet on Another Christian woman gives… cinhosa on Another Christian woman gives… Chicago’s Cardinal F… on Chicago’s Cardinal Franc… Catholic mass on Six+ decades of Dutch Roman Ca… Our del.icio.us
Tags
abortion abstinence Anglican anonymous blogging anti-abortion anti-Semitism Atlanta Baptist Barack Obama Cameroon Catholic Catholic church CDC children child sexual abuse child trafficking Christian Christianity Christmas clerical predators clerical sexual abuse clerical sexual predation condoms creationism cult culture wars deacons Eddie Long Episcopal evolution Faith-Based Initiatives FBC Jax Florida gay genocide global warming Great Commission Resurgence Great Commission Resurgence Task Force Haiti hate crime health care reform health reform homophobia homosexual homosexuality human rights International Mission Board Jacksonville journalism Legionaires of Christ lgbt rights Marcial Maciel Muslim Obama pedophile priests Pope Benedict XVI Regnum Christe Religion Religious Right Richard Land Rick Warren roman catholic church same-sex marriage Sarah Palin SBC Scientology sexual predators Southern Baptist Southern Baptist Convention SSPX Ted Haggard Texas Uganda Vatican Wade Burleson womenBlogs by Month
Catholic News Service
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Associated Baptist Press
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Spiritual Politics
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Stop Baptist Predators
- Hopeless and Hopeful: Reflections on the past and thoughts for the future
- Common misconceptions about the Baylor sexual assault scandal
- SBC church seeks to 'out' child sex abuse victims
- Southern Baptists elect known clergy-sex-abuse-cover-upper as president
- SNAP prediction: Next "Spotlight"-style exposé will focus on Baptists
- What's wrong with the "sexual predation" resolution
- Why Ted Cruz should see "Spotlight"
- Spotlight: Lessons to be Learned
- "Frankly, this ruling is appropriate ...."
- Mitigating the trauma of clergy sex abuse
Tony Cartledge
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Religion Clause
- European Court: Romania Violated European Convention When It Reversed Conviction of 2 Nazi War Criminals
- Recent Articles of Interest
- Washington State AG Investigating Sex Abuse Cover-Up by Catholic Diocese
- Religious Discrimination Claim for Denial of Personal Leave Moves Ahead
- 10th Circuit: Vaccine Exemption for Only Some Religions Violates 1st Amendment
- Indiana Suit Seeks Release of Reports from Abortion Providers
- 4th Circuit: Ministerial Exception Bars Suit by Catholic School Teacher Fired Over Same-Sex Marriage Plans
- Court Says NY Proposed Amendment on Abortion, Sexual Orientation and Gender May Not Go on Ballot
- NY Sues Crisis Pregnancy Centers for False Advertising
- Alabama May Not Prosecute Those Who Arrange Out-of-State Abortions for Women
Grace & Truth to You
- Wade Burleson at Istoria Ministries Is Now A Substack Subscription
- "A Revolution that Began in the Hearts and Minds of the American People" - by President John Adams
- Graced People Reap What They Have Not Sown; Lost People Reap What They Have Sown
- Wade Burleson Is Now at Istoria Ministries
- 2021 World's Tallest Live Christmas Tree, Enid, OK
- Be My Thou Thanksgiving Vision: A Prayer for All
- Chasa Boudin and San Francisco's Crime Wave
- Let's Be Thankful that "This Is My Father's World"
- Addictions and the Goal to Control God's Thoughts
- The Potential Discovery of Lt. Col. Leon "Bob" Vance's Crashed Army Air Corp Air Ambulance
Get Religion
- Farewell, after 20 years: Why we did what we did
- Peter J. Boyer: Charged with covering faith for The New Yorker, I found GetReligion
- Salute from Will Norton at Ole Miss: Religion plays a crucial role in news -- around the world
- Closing one door: Whither 21st Century religion and our beleaguered news media?
- Thomas A. Szyszkiewicz: A farewell to GetReligion from Catholic radio
- Archbishop Charles J. Chaput: The religion beat is where 'our defining freedoms meet'
- Julia Duin: It's been a long road and we've reached the end of our GetReligion journey
- A salute from north of the border, care of CBC Radio veteran Anna-Liza Kozma
- Farewell from Moscow: This American ran into GetReligion online and never stopped reading
- Kenneth Woodward: GetReligion, in so many ways, kept offering on-the-job training
Faith in Public Life
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
dotCommonweal
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Capital J
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
@baptistplanet on twitter
Tweets by baptistplanet
[…] minutes from lack of health insurance While Baptist Press promoted Kelly Bloggs’ shrill, CounterFactual, anti-abortion attack on health care reform, Eduardo Peñalver of Cornell Law School struggled with […]
Pingback by A death every 12 minutes from lack of health insurance « BaptistPlanet | September 20, 2009
With respect to the assertions above regarding the Planned Parenthood Federation of America (PPFA): The figures cited, while they may be literally accurate, also might convey a misleading impression. PPFA has a big stake in abortion – it is the nation’s largest abortion provider. In 2007, PPFA-affiliated clinics performed 305,310 abortions. Abortions account for around one-third of all the income taken in at PPFA-affiliated clinics. Documentation is here: http://www.nrlc.org/Factsheets/PPFAMoney.pdf
and here:
Click to access PPAbortion.pdf
and here: http://www.nrlc.org/onlinebrochures/Downloadables/Articles/PlannedParenthoodEmpireWeeklyStandard.pdf
Still, PPFA regularly complains that barriers to “access” prevent many abortions. For example, the Guttmacher Institute, long affiliated with PPFA, has estimated that about one-fourth of the women who would have received abortions with federal Medicaid funds, instead gave birth, because of the Hyde Amendment. PPFA/Guttmacher sees that as a problem. We see it as a success — it means that more than one million Americans are alive today because of the Hyde Amendment. Thus, the Hyde Amendment is arguably the single most successful domestic abortion-reduction law ever adopted by Congress. Yet, Barack Obama has always opposed the Hyde Amendment and all other proposals to genuinely bar government funding of abortion, a position that he reiterated during his presidential campaign, and a position that he has never recanted.
Douglas Johnson
Legislative Director
National Right to Life Committee
Washington, D.C.
Legfederal–at–aol,dot,com
Comment by Douglas Johnson | September 21, 2009
[…] Counterfactual Kelly has a couple of other, even more poorly examined examples of the behavior he ascribes to a group he terms “neo-liberals.” Like Bigfoot, Boggs Neo-liberals may exist. […]
Pingback by Boggs Neo-liberals « BaptistPlanet | October 19, 2009