Comes the Inquisition: 2000 BF&M
Moves toward disfellowship of First Baptist Church, Decatur, Ga., for calling a woman (Julie Pennington-Russell) as senior pastor have become the prevailing measure of the Southern Baptist Convention’s (SBC) descent to inquisitorial enforcement of the 2000 Baptist Faith and Message (BF&M).
The historic SBC tenet “We have no creed but the Bible” is dead, mourned Texas pastor Ken Coffee on Jan. 28. FBC Decatur’s prospective disfellowship and other actions mark the rise of the SBC’s BF&M 2000 to the status of creed. Coffee outlines the history of the BF&M 2000 inquisition, observing by way of pointed introduction:
Now, it should be noted here that Texas Baptists as a convention (BGCT) have never adopted the 2000 BF&M. Texas still uses the 1963 version, which some have called the finest such document ever written. One wonders why the SBC has not kicked the BGCT out for not adolpting the 2000 BF&M. Could it have anything to do with money?
Even absent attack on an entire association, current enforcement of the theologically flawed BF&M 2000 as creed is “absurd,” and could tear apart what remains of the SBC, warns Oklahoma pastor Wade Burleson.
Burleson wrote:
The FORCED acceptance of the BFM 2000, by threatening to “disfellowship” from those churches who don’t agree with every single one of its tenets, is patently absurd. Those who push “disfellowship” from churches that disagree with a portion of the BFM 2000 will destroy our convention if they are allowed to succeed. The SBC will have to eventually disfellowship from over 25,000 Southern Baptist churches. That is the number of SBC churches, at least according to one seminary professor, that have expressed disagreement with the BFM 2000 in either church practice or church doctrine in areas other than women pastors.
Burleson identifies “closed communion” as a BF&M 2000 doctrine with which “most Southern Baptist churches and pastors disagree.” And throws down the gauntlet on that issue himself. For on that and other issues, he refuses to join those who have have “elevated a creed above the Bible!“
Lost amid the confused enforcement of BF&M 2000 as a creed, Ms. Pennington-Russell wrote in her Jan. 23 newsletter to her congregation, is the fundamental purpose of the church:
May God save us from the deadly notion that this church exists to provide goods and services for eligible “members.” If anything, the witness of Scripture shows us that the church exists for the sake of the world. We exist to worship God and invest ourselves in bringing Christ’s kingdom on earth. We exist to discern and to do God’s will in an ever-changing world. We exist to follow Jesus into gospel adventures of all kinds in collaboration with all of God’s people, whatever their denominational preferences or doctrinal stances.
There is no bedrock Baptist justification for the distraction from core church mission by BF&M “bullying,” Burleson argues. It is “ungodly, unbaptistic and ridiculous” and “must stop.” And stopping it, as with stopping bullies on a school playground, is a matter of confronting the bullies. In this case, a matter of confronting the bullies with the truth.
For as Coffee explains, “the BF&M was intended to be nothing more than a guide to churches to help them understand whether or not they wanted to be included in the fellowship of churches we call the denomination. It was never intended as a document for excluding churches. No church that would say they disagree with most points of the BF&M would want to cooperate with the denomination.”
February 1, 2009 - Posted by baptistplanet | Religion | Baptist Faith & Message 2000, BR&M, FBC Decatur, Julie Pennington-Russell, SBC, Southern Baptist Convention
2 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
About BaptistPlanet
BaptistPlanet is a multiblog written by two prize-winning, veteran, mainstream daily newspaper and online journalists. Both Southerners. We cover every aspect of religion news that is of interest to our audience.
Categories
Top Posts
- Southern Contrived Chicken
- Evangelical Protestants are in the declining minority on gay marriage
- Clerical sexual offenders are different (perhaps not in the ways you think).
- The (irrational) politics of religion prevailed in South Carolina
- Rector of thousand-year-old greek monestary arrested/charged with embezzlement
- 'Weird' Bible verse from Vintage Faith Church
Recent Comments
Scott Rose on Civil marriage debate is owed… cinhosa on Another Christian woman gives… baptistplanet on Another Christian woman gives… cinhosa on Another Christian woman gives… Chicago’s Cardinal F… on Chicago’s Cardinal Franc… Catholic mass on Six+ decades of Dutch Roman Ca… Our del.icio.us
Tags
abortion abstinence Anglican anonymous blogging anti-abortion anti-Semitism Atlanta Baptist Barack Obama Cameroon Catholic Catholic church CDC children child sexual abuse child trafficking Christian Christianity Christmas clerical predators clerical sexual abuse clerical sexual predation condoms creationism cult culture wars deacons Eddie Long Episcopal evolution Faith-Based Initiatives FBC Jax Florida gay genocide global warming Great Commission Resurgence Great Commission Resurgence Task Force Haiti hate crime health care reform health reform homophobia homosexual homosexuality human rights International Mission Board Jacksonville journalism Legionaires of Christ lgbt rights Marcial Maciel Muslim Obama pedophile priests Pope Benedict XVI Regnum Christe Religion Religious Right Richard Land Rick Warren roman catholic church same-sex marriage Sarah Palin SBC Scientology sexual predators Southern Baptist Southern Baptist Convention SSPX Ted Haggard Texas Uganda Vatican Wade Burleson womenBlogs by Month
Catholic News Service
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Associated Baptist Press
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Spiritual Politics
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Stop Baptist Predators
- Hopeless and Hopeful: Reflections on the past and thoughts for the future
- Common misconceptions about the Baylor sexual assault scandal
- SBC church seeks to 'out' child sex abuse victims
- Southern Baptists elect known clergy-sex-abuse-cover-upper as president
- SNAP prediction: Next "Spotlight"-style exposé will focus on Baptists
- What's wrong with the "sexual predation" resolution
- Why Ted Cruz should see "Spotlight"
- Spotlight: Lessons to be Learned
- "Frankly, this ruling is appropriate ...."
- Mitigating the trauma of clergy sex abuse
Tony Cartledge
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Religion Clause
- New Report Finds 63% of Americans Support Legalized Abortion
- European Court: Romania Violated European Convention When It Reversed Conviction of 2 Nazi War Criminals
- Recent Articles of Interest
- Washington State AG Investigating Sex Abuse Cover-Up by Catholic Diocese
- Religious Discrimination Claim for Denial of Personal Leave Moves Ahead
- 10th Circuit: Vaccine Exemption for Only Some Religions Violates 1st Amendment
- Indiana Suit Seeks Release of Reports from Abortion Providers
- 4th Circuit: Ministerial Exception Bars Suit by Catholic School Teacher Fired Over Same-Sex Marriage Plans
- Court Says NY Proposed Amendment on Abortion, Sexual Orientation and Gender May Not Go on Ballot
- NY Sues Crisis Pregnancy Centers for False Advertising
Grace & Truth to You
- Wade Burleson at Istoria Ministries Is Now A Substack Subscription
- "A Revolution that Began in the Hearts and Minds of the American People" - by President John Adams
- Graced People Reap What They Have Not Sown; Lost People Reap What They Have Sown
- Wade Burleson Is Now at Istoria Ministries
- 2021 World's Tallest Live Christmas Tree, Enid, OK
- Be My Thou Thanksgiving Vision: A Prayer for All
- Chasa Boudin and San Francisco's Crime Wave
- Let's Be Thankful that "This Is My Father's World"
- Addictions and the Goal to Control God's Thoughts
- The Potential Discovery of Lt. Col. Leon "Bob" Vance's Crashed Army Air Corp Air Ambulance
Get Religion
- Farewell, after 20 years: Why we did what we did
- Peter J. Boyer: Charged with covering faith for The New Yorker, I found GetReligion
- Salute from Will Norton at Ole Miss: Religion plays a crucial role in news -- around the world
- Closing one door: Whither 21st Century religion and our beleaguered news media?
- Thomas A. Szyszkiewicz: A farewell to GetReligion from Catholic radio
- Archbishop Charles J. Chaput: The religion beat is where 'our defining freedoms meet'
- Julia Duin: It's been a long road and we've reached the end of our GetReligion journey
- A salute from north of the border, care of CBC Radio veteran Anna-Liza Kozma
- Farewell from Moscow: This American ran into GetReligion online and never stopped reading
- Kenneth Woodward: GetReligion, in so many ways, kept offering on-the-job training
Faith in Public Life
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
dotCommonweal
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Capital J
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
@baptistplanet on twitter
Tweets by baptistplanet
[…] message was in marked contrast to the Southern Baptist Convention’s ongoing inquisitorial […]
Pingback by ‘Division like a cancer’ for Baptists, Carter tells New Baptist Covenant « BaptistPlanet | February 1, 2009
[…] should Baptists disfellowship women-pastored churches? The Georgia Baptist Convention’s disfellowshipping of First Baptist Church, Decatur, merely formalizes something that happened when Julie […]
Pingback by Why should Baptists disfellowship women-pastored churches? « BaptistPlanet | February 2, 2009